Welcome to the annual selection of my ten top films of the year. I say “top” films rather than “favourite” or “greatest” because, in truth, I can’t really consider any of these favourites without a second watch, and some of these I’ve only seen once. However, my final selection made enough of an impression to wind up on this list. As for “greatest”, my views on that are well documented, ie I don’t consider a film “great” or a “classic” (a term carelessly chucked around by less thoughtful film commenters) until at least ten years have allowed it to mature to that status, like a good single malt whisky. For more of my thoughts on what constitutes a great film, by all means, disappear down this rabbit hole.
Some additional points on criteria: To qualify for this list, the film in question has to have had a UK cinema release (even a limited one) during 2022, and I have to have seen it in the cinema. Films only available on streaming are ineligible, as they therefore aren’t “cinema” by definition, but more like “TV Movies”, as they used to be called. No, I don’t care if that makes me sound like a curmudgeonly “gatekeeper” (if you’ll forgive my use of an immensely irritating term I see splattered around these days, with reference to people who actually know a damn thing about cinema history). I may have made some allowances during the pandemic, but 2022 was the first year cinemas were open without interruption since 2019, so no more of this newfangled streaming nonsense. Cinema is the primary place to see films, and that is a tenet of the Dillon Empire carved in stone for all eternity.
Another critical point of order: I refer you again to the opening of my previous paragraph: To qualify, the film has to have been released in the UK in 2022. I am well aware US release dates are sometimes different, and indeed release dates differ throughout the rest of the world. However, my list is based purely on UK release dates, hence no mention of films such as Tár, The Whale, Babylon, Empire of Light, or The Fabelmans (all due for release in the UK early next year, so will qualify for my 2023 list, should they prove worthy).
On a related note, I didn’t get the chance to see The Lost Daughter, The Tragedy of Macbeth, and The Power of the Dog until early this year, when in fact they were all 2021 UK releases. Why did I wait? I wanted to see them at the cinema, not on streaming, and where I live in southwest England, sometimes that means I have to wait for them to show up at independent venues. But I never regret waiting. True love waits, and all that. And yes, at least one of those films (The Power of the Dog) would have been on my 2021 list, edging out another film. So one has to bear in mind the inevitability of such excellent films occasionally falling through the cracks.
What didn’t make the cut?
Before I get to the list, first a quick glide through my cinematic year. The first film I saw in 2022 was The Electrical Life of Louis Wain; a quirky, enjoyable piece of work that I was sad to leave on the sidelines. Parallel Mothers is another one I regret omitting, despite its flaws. Lots of people loved Belfast, but it didn’t hit the spot for me in quite the same way. And despite the deluge of critical praise heaped on cinematic art-installation piece Memoria, quite frankly I nearly fell asleep watching it.
Nor did I have my sights on The Eyes of Tammy Faye, or the immensely entertaining trio of The Duke, The Phantom of the Open, and The Lost King. Leaving out the latter was particularly painful, as I enjoyed it so much, despite certain shortcomings. By contrast, I didn’t particularly mind omitting Red Rocket, as I much preferred Sean Baker’s previous film, The Florida Project. Nor did I mind leaving out Everything Everywhere All At Once; a film everyone except me seems to love, but I found it exhausting and headache-inducing. A shame, as I really wanted to like it.
Drive My Car proved more positive, though I found it overlong, and Ali & Ava is worth a special mention too, despite also failing to secure a slot in the top ten. No space either for potential Oscar contenders She Said and The Woman King, both strong films. Nor could I fit in romantic comedy Mr Malcolm’s List, despite being thoroughly charmed by it. Leaving out Bowie celebration Moonage Daydream also hurt a little.
Moving on to blockbusters, The Lost City proved a modestly enjoyable riff on Romancing the Stone, but it wasn’t memorable enough to include. Jurassic World: Dominion was an utter disappointment, and the less said about James Cameron’s wet fish Avatar: The Way of Water, the better. On the plus side, Top Gun: Maverick flew its way into blockbuster history, smashing all manner of box office records. I enjoyed it, will concede it is an improvement on the original film in every respect except the soundtrack, but I don’t think it is as good as many have claimed.
Animation-wise, it’s not been a stellar year; or at least, not in mainstream Hollywood. I suppose The Bob’s Burgers Movie was enjoyable, as was The Bad Guys, and Minions: The Rise of Gru did what I expected of it. By contrast, Disney and Pixar seem hellbent on streaming self-harm, denying a gem like Turning Red a cinema release, and putting out superfluous Toy Story spin-off Lightyear instead. As for the interminably preachy Strange World, please don’t get me started. On a more positive note, I enjoyed anime Beauty and the Beast variant Belle quite a bit, even if it did rather try and bludgeon me into touchy-feely emo submission. Even more positive are the two outstanding animated films that made my top ten, about which more in a moment.
Superhero films seem to have hit a rather indifferent patch this year. I enjoyed Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness and even the much-maligned Thor: Love and Thunder, but neither hit anything like the highs of previous Marvel endeavours. As for Black Panther: Wakanda Forever, I found it rather dull, despite the undeniably poignant open and close, paying tribute to Chadwick Boseman. Black Adam didn’t do much for me either and I think it’s best for all concerned if we draw a veil over Morbius. I suppose The Batman is the closest thing we had to a solid superhero film this year, though it is somewhat overlong and fell short of Christopher Nolan’s magnificent Dark Knight trilogy.
Quite honestly, I’ve rather had it up to here with superhero films, and I think we could all do with a decade-long moratorium on the genre. Perhaps that way, some more interesting and original filmmaking could come out of mainstream Hollywood. Yes, I know that’s unlikely to happen. Still, I can dream.
On the other hand, as with 2021, this has been a fine year for horror films. The Black Phone, X, Crimes of the Future, Smile, Barbarian, Bones and All, and The Menu all caught my eye for one reason or another. Some were more flawed than others, but all proved imaginative and interesting, not to mention scary and disturbing. There are two horror films in my final selection, as you’ll see in a moment. I’ve also seen a good clutch of thrillers this year, including The Outfit, Beast, Fall, See How They Run, Glass Onion, and Watcher. Some of those I also regret omitting from this list, especially the last three.
On a different note, I want to give a special shout to Matilda: The Musical. This opulent, charming musical adaptation of the Roald Dahl classic is my favourite “family” film of the year, in the sense that most people understand the term. Personally, I don’t like to say “family film” as “family” isn’t a genre, and one could argue The Godfather is a “family” film. But I’m sure you take my point, ie that it’s a lovely film for all ages. I’m just sorry US audiences appear to be only getting it on streaming, which frankly is not on. I suggest taking to the streets in protest against streaming. Down with this sort of thing, as Father Ted would say.
Finally, there were certain films I found it excruciating to leave out. Consider these numbers 15 to 11 in my countdown: The Souvenir: Part II, Elvis, Licorice Pizza, Un Monde (Playground), and Guillermo Del Toro’s stunning remake of Nightmare Alley. Leaving out the latter hurts my cinematic soul, but thankfully Del Toro is represented elsewhere in the top ten.
Without any further ado, here’s my top ten.
10. Living
Bill Nighy’s standout performance is the centrepiece of this poignant, low-key gem from Oliver Hermanus and Kazuo Ishiguro. Adapting Akira Kurosawa’s Ikiru (itself partly inspired by Tolstoy’s The Death of Ivan Ilyich) they conclusively prove not all remakes are bad. Nighy’s indifferent life as a post-war London bureaucrat is given a shake-up when he receives bad news from the doctor. He wants to do something of significance with what is left of his life, and after forming a close friendship with the much younger Aimee Lou Wood, he finds a new purpose. Melancholy, elegiac, and bittersweet, this gets under the skin in true Ishiguro style. Expect Oscar nominations to follow.
9. Flee
As far as I’m concerned, Flee deserved to win Best International Film, Best Animated Film, and Best Documentary at this year’s Oscars. It was nominated for all three but won nothing. A crying shame, as this stunningly animated account of an Afghan refugee’s traumatic journey is harrowing but immensely gripping. Director Jonas Poher Rasmussen’s creativity eats the screen, with imagery ranging from detailed colour to monochrome minimalism for the darker moments. Covering a range of incident including the subject’s encounters with human traffickers, corrupt post-Soviet Russian police, coming to terms with homosexuality, and the ever-present threat of being sent back to a home country caught in a vicious cycle of war and religious extremism, Flee is riveting cinema.
8. The Northman
Director Robert Eggers continues to impress with this vivid, bloody, bonkers tale of Viking vengeance. Featuring a muscular central performance from Alexander Skarsgård and a committed turn from the always excellent Anja Taylor-Joy, this may be infused with mythology and madness, but never at the expense of realism. As spectacle, this is top-notch stuff, with sublime icy Nordic visuals particularly impressive on the big screen, where you can all but feel the shivering winds amid the gruesome mayhem. Nicole Kidman also appears in the supporting cast, and has a standout scene worth the price of admission alone.
7. Pinnochio
Do we really need another film of Pinocchio? Apparently, we do. Guilllermo Del Toro’s masterful stop-motion animation adaptation of Carlo Collodi’s novel puts a subversive, surreal, surprisingly moving spin on the timeless fairy tale. Ignore those mollycoddling twits saying this is too alarming for children. Yes, Del Toro’s take embraces dark themes, but the discussions around death and grief are handled in a way that I consider entirely appropriate for family audiences. Not only does it look stunning, but Del Toro adds strongly anti-fascist, anti-authoritarian undertones, and has interesting things to say about the nature of father/son relationships. In short, it’s a beautiful piece of work, and my favourite animated film of 2022.
6. Verdens Verste Menneske (The Worst Person in the World)
Renate Reinsve is brilliant as the protagonist of Joachim Trier’s Oscar-nominated Norwegian drama that pretends to be a romantic comedy. In fact, the tone is more tragicomic, with emotionally messy coming-of-age threads woven into the sublimely enjoyable whole. As one of Reinsve’s romantic interests, Anders Danielsen Lie plays a particularly interesting supporting character who I found oddly relatable. One particularly euphoric sequence, involving a moment when time is frozen, remains one of the most exhilarating pieces of filmmaking I’ve seen all year.
5. Nope
A blockbusting nail-biter that both celebrates and critiques Hollywood spectacle, featuring great lead performances from Daniel Kaluuya and Keke Palmer. Some criticised Jordan Peele’s unusual sci-fi monster movie as being too narratively dense and lacking the discipline of his earlier films like Get Out. I don’t agree. If anything, I enjoyed Nope even more. Like Christopher Nolan and Denis Villeneuve, Peele is one of an increasingly rare breed: An uncompromised auteur filmmaker working in mainstream Hollywood. His work here is singular and brilliant, filled with unique images best appreciated on an IMAX screen.
4. De Uskyldige (The Innocents)
The second Norwegian film on this list, and my favourite horror film of the year. This kids-with-powers tale swiftly abandons X-Men territory for something more Village of the Damned-ish, but remains very much its own beast. Director Eskil Vogt retains a grounded realism throughout, not defining anyone as an outright villain, despite some appalling acts (including hideous animal cruelty). When events escalate into murder, even then Vogt is careful to paint these children as emotionally immature, complex characters, whose backgrounds as well as poor impulse control have a bearing on their actions. This just makes it even more disturbing, especially as the adults remain oblivious to events throughout.
3. Decision to Leave
Park Chan-wook’s twisty-turny romantic thriller features electrifying chemistry between insomniac detective Park Hae-il and murder suspect Tang Wei. Both the romantic elements and the thriller aspects are brilliantly handled, with Chan-wook’s innovative directorial style playing with points of view and fantasy versus reality to sublime effect. For instance, the way Park Hae-il imagines himself in scenes where he wasn’t present isn’t just a gimmick but becomes increasingly visually important as an indicator of his state of mind. An undercurrent of dark humour plays out in the detective sequences, with the romance building a vividly melodramatic head of steam that lingers long in the consciousness. In short, this is right up my street, and I absolutely loved it.
2. The Banshees of Inisherin
On a small Irish island circa 1923, Brendan Gleeson and Colin Farrell go from friendship to feud. Although laced with pitch-black comedy, this is a profoundly sad tale on several levels, with Gleeson’s digit-severing self-mutilation threats both a potent metaphor for the Irish political situation of the time, and an astute comment on male pride. In some ways, the key character in the film isn’t Gleeson or Farrell, but the troubled character played (brilliantly) by Barry Keoghan. He’s considered the village idiot, but revealed as someone far more complex, thoughtful, and troubled, with his subplot beautifully interwoven with the main plot, adding sublime layers of irony. Brilliantly written, acted, and directed, and featuring atmospheric island landscapes that make great use of Aran Island locations, this darkly hilarious but unsettling drama ought to go on to Oscar nominations.
1. Aftersun
I agonised over whether this or The Banshees of Inisherin should be my number one choice. In the end, I’m opting for Charlotte Wells’s extraordinary debut feature, as I found it so hauntingly moving. This small miracle of a film may not sound remarkable in terms of plot; a single father and his adolescent daughter bonding during a holiday in a Turkish resort circa the late 1990s. But the luminous atmosphere of understated poignancy, simultaneously realistic and dreamlike, elevates this exploration of parent-child relationships, coming of age, loss, and the nature of memory to deep and profound effect.
Wells makes particularly clever use of reflective surfaces, which adds to the feeling of vivid recollection of a halcyon past. Paul Mescal and Frankie Corio deliver performances that are so convincing, I kept forgetting they were actors. The deftly deployed slow burn of tiny details emotionally creep up on you, culminating in an astonishing final shot that lingers long in the consciousness. You won’t listen to Under Pressure by Queen and David Bowie in the same way ever again. A perfectly formed gem that left me in tears, and my favourite film of 2022.
That’s (almost) it for 2022. Next year, an inevitable glut of superheroes, sequels, and reboots looms on the horizon. I confess I’m not enthralled at the prospect of any of these, save the second part of Denis Villeneuve’s Dune adaptation, and I suppose the next Mission Impossible may be fun. I am looking forward to Tár, The Fabelmans, Oppenheimer, and a few others. Megan looks agreeably nasty too. However, I suspect as with this year, the bulk of the cinematic gold will be found outside mainstream Hollywood.